Call your local brokerage at 855.875.8640

Shelter Island, NY Real Estate — Homes For Sale in Shelter Island, NY

29 Properties Found [ Edit Search ]
Favorite this property Click the heart icon to add this property to your favorites list Save This Search
Receive Email Alerts
First page 1 of 2 Last
$525,000
$1,857/mo
Monthly Payment:
$1,857
Principal & Interest:
$1,857
HOA Dues:
$0
(Based on a 30 year fixed loan at 3.38% with $105,000 down)
Shelter Island, NY 11964
Shelter Island Union Free School District
3bed 1bath 1,421sq ft $369 / sq ft SFR
Lot Size14,810sq ft Built1858 On Site14days
Authentic Farmhouse In The Heart Of The Center, This Three Bedroom Home Has A Great Deal Of Potential. Convenient To All, Adjacent To The School Playground, The Property Would... more
Authentic Farmhouse In The Heart Of The Center, This Three Bedroom Home Has A Great Deal Of Potential. Convenient To All, Adjacent To The School Playground, The Property Would Be A Great Investment For A Young Family. less
Listing Provided Courtesy of DANIEL GALE SOTHEBYS INTL RLTY
Popularity
We show you every available listing. Here's how
$1,600,000
$5,662/mo
Monthly Payment:
$5,662
Principal & Interest:
$5,662
HOA Dues:
$0
(Based on a 30 year fixed loan at 3.38% with $320,000 down)
Shelter Island, NY 11964
Shelter Island Union Free School District
4bed 3bath 2,532sq ft $632 / sq ft SFR
Lot Size23,087sq ft Built1964 On Site16days
Lovely Classic New England Cape, Beautiful Water Views, Pristine Location. Located On A Private Road, Cesspool, Well, Waterfront.
Lovely Classic New England Cape, Beautiful Water Views, Pristine Location. Located On A Private Road, Cesspool, Well, Waterfront. less
Listing Provided Courtesy of LAFFEY FINE HOMES
Popularity
$1,475,000
$5,220/mo
Monthly Payment:
$5,220
Principal & Interest:
$5,220
HOA Dues:
$0
(Based on a 30 year fixed loan at 3.38% with $295,000 down)
Shelter Island, NY 11964
Shelter Island Union Free School District
4bed 5bath 3,017sq ft $489 / sq ft SFR
Lot Size16,117sq ft Built1987 On Site17days
Waterfront Modern At Water's Edge With Dock, Waterside; Wrap Around Dining Deck, Pergula + 2nd Floor Verandas In Private Bucolic Setting. Quiet + Across From Large Waterfront... more
Waterfront Modern At Water's Edge With Dock, Waterside; Wrap Around Dining Deck, Pergula + 2nd Floor Verandas In Private Bucolic Setting. Quiet + Across From Large Waterfront Preserve. Spacious, Stylish + Recently Renovated, Italian Custom Cabinetry, Open Kitchen, Dr, Lr Have Doors To Deck + Dining Al Fresco. 2 Roomy Dens, Gym, Man Cave/Shop, New Roof + Skylights In 2014. less
Listing Provided Courtesy of DANIEL GALE SOTHEBYS INTL RLTY
Popularity
$975,000
$3,450/mo
Monthly Payment:
$3,450
Principal & Interest:
$3,450
HOA Dues:
$0
(Based on a 30 year fixed loan at 3.38% with $195,000 down)
Shelter Island, NY 11964
Shelter Island Union Free School District
4bed 4bath N/Asq ft N/A / sq ft SFR
Lot Size43,560sq ft Built2001 On Site21days
Very Unique Opportunity To Own And Invest Some Capital & Upgrade The Cosmetics Of The House To Your Own Style As This House Is 100% Complete But Based Upon Your Taste And Budget... more
Very Unique Opportunity To Own And Invest Some Capital & Upgrade The Cosmetics Of The House To Your Own Style As This House Is 100% Complete But Based Upon Your Taste And Budget Has Room To Be Brought To The Superior Level This Master Builder Had In Mind. Everything Is There But Needs Tlc As Its Not Perfect But With A Little $ Can Iincrease Value! less
Listing Provided Courtesy of TOWN AND COUNTRY REAL ESTATE
Popularity
$1,350,000
$4,777/mo
Monthly Payment:
$4,777
Principal & Interest:
$4,777
HOA Dues:
$0
(Based on a 30 year fixed loan at 3.38% with $270,000 down)
Shelter Island, NY 11964
Shelter Island Union Free School District
5bed 4bath 2,299sq ft $587 / sq ft SFR
Lot Size33,977sq ft Built2003 On Site27days
5 bed, 3.5 bath home in silver beach of shelter island. Located on wheeler canal w/ beautiful water views & dock & w/in close proximity to shell beach. Open floor plan with... more
5 bed, 3.5 bath home in silver beach of shelter island. Located on wheeler canal w/ beautiful water views & dock & w/in close proximity to shell beach. Open floor plan with living room, gas fireplace, dining, stainless & granite kitchen, updated tiled baths, master suite, finished basement with gym & media area. A waterside deck with 20x40 gunite pool. Easy boating access less
Listing Provided Courtesy of CORCORAN
Popularity
$759,000
$2,686/mo
Monthly Payment:
$2,686
Principal & Interest:
$2,686
HOA Dues:
$0
(Based on a 30 year fixed loan at 3.38% with $151,800 down)
Shelter Island, NY 11964
Shelter Island Union Free School District
3bed 3bath 1,894sq ft $401 / sq ft SFR
Lot Size40,075sq ft Built2014 On Site30days
Newly Built Sun-Filled 2-Story Home Overlooks Landscaped Property Lush Woods W/ Water Views Room For Pool+Tennis Court. Soaring Foyer Entrance. Lr W/ Fireplace+Outdoor Deck Mbr... more
Newly Built Sun-Filled 2-Story Home Overlooks Landscaped Property Lush Woods W/ Water Views Room For Pool+Tennis Court. Soaring Foyer Entrance. Lr W/ Fireplace+Outdoor Deck Mbr Suite On Ground Fl, All Brs W/ Outdoor Decks. Walls Of Windows Watch Sunrise+Sunset. Blondwood Floors Ss Appliances Brushed Chrome Fixtures Granite Countertops In Kitchen. Walk To Beach, Restaurants less
Listing Provided Courtesy of REALMART REALTY LLC
Popularity
$749,000
$2,650/mo
Monthly Payment:
$2,650
Principal & Interest:
$2,650
HOA Dues:
$0
(Based on a 30 year fixed loan at 3.38% with $149,800 down)
Shelter Island, NY 11964
Shelter Island Union Free School District
5bed 3bath 2,700sq ft $277 / sq ft SFR
Lot Size1.1acre Built1984 On Site49days
Close To Harbor And Sandy Beach! Beautiful Light Fills This House With Kitchen, Dining/Liv Room, Large Deck, Master Suite, And Guest Bdrm On 2nd Floor. Den, 2 Bedrms, Full Bath,... more
Close To Harbor And Sandy Beach! Beautiful Light Fills This House With Kitchen, Dining/Liv Room, Large Deck, Master Suite, And Guest Bdrm On 2nd Floor. Den, 2 Bedrms, Full Bath, Mudroom & Uitilities On 1st. 2 Car Garage With Guest Quarters/Artist Studio & Full Bath Above. This 1+ Acre Has Room For Pool, Gardening, And Your Personal Touch! less
Listing Provided Courtesy of DANIEL GALE SOTHEBYS INTL RLTY
Popularity
$889,000
$3,146/mo
Monthly Payment:
$3,146
Principal & Interest:
$3,146
HOA Dues:
$0
(Based on a 30 year fixed loan at 3.38% with $177,800 down)
Shelter Island, NY 11964
Shelter Island Union Free School District
N/Asq ft N/A / sq ft LND
Lot Size4.0acre BuiltN/A On Site54days
4 Rolling Acres With Incredible Elevation. Enjoy The Summer Southwest Summer Breezes On This Incomparable Hilltop. Use Your Creativity And Create Your Very Private Summer Or... more
4 Rolling Acres With Incredible Elevation. Enjoy The Summer Southwest Summer Breezes On This Incomparable Hilltop. Use Your Creativity And Create Your Very Private Summer Or Year Round Estate. Electric, Cable & Verizon In Place. Also Available In Combination With 5.5 Acres Of 72 S Ferry Road For An Amazing 9.5 Acre Piece. less
Listing Provided Courtesy of DANIEL GALE SOTHEBYS INTL RLTY
Popularity
$1,850,000
$6,547/mo
Monthly Payment:
$6,547
Principal & Interest:
$6,547
HOA Dues:
$0
(Based on a 30 year fixed loan at 3.38% with $370,000 down)
Shelter Island, NY 11964
Shelter Island Union Free School District
1bed 1bath 1,800sq ft $1,028 / sq ft SFR
Lot Size5.5acre Built1998 On Site54days
Artists Dream Studio Surrounded By 5.5 Acres Of Gardens, Pond And Nature. Stunningly Redone Infinity Heated Pool And Hot Tub, High On The Bluff Overlooking All! Also Available... more
Artists Dream Studio Surrounded By 5.5 Acres Of Gardens, Pond And Nature. Stunningly Redone Infinity Heated Pool And Hot Tub, High On The Bluff Overlooking All! Also Available In Combination With 131 S Midway Road, With An Additional 4 Acres, For An Elegant 9.5 Acre Estate. less
Listing Provided Courtesy of DANIEL GALE SOTHEBYS INTL RLTY
Popularity
$425,000
$1,504/mo
Monthly Payment:
$1,504
Principal & Interest:
$1,504
HOA Dues:
$0
(Based on a 30 year fixed loan at 3.38% with $85,000 down)
Shelter Island, NY 11964
Shelter Island Union Free School District
N/Asq ft N/A / sq ft LND
Lot Size34,848sq ft BuiltN/A On Site54days
Level, Cleared, Shy Acre With Water View, Ready For Your Island Home. This .8 Acre Property Is Conveniently Located Near The Town Center With Shops, Restaurants, Library,... more
Level, Cleared, Shy Acre With Water View, Ready For Your Island Home. This .8 Acre Property Is Conveniently Located Near The Town Center With Shops, Restaurants, Library, Playgrounds And More. Near Wades Beach, And Central On The Island, This Is An Ideal Location! Across The Street, #8 South Midway Road, Also For Sale At $875,000. less
Listing Provided Courtesy of DANIEL GALE SOTHEBYS INTL RLTY
Popularity
$875,000
$3,096/mo
Monthly Payment:
$3,096
Principal & Interest:
$3,096
HOA Dues:
$0
(Based on a 30 year fixed loan at 3.38% with $175,000 down)
Shelter Island, NY 11964
Shelter Island Union Free School District
3bed 2bath 2,552sq ft $343 / sq ft SFR
Lot Size42,537sq ft Built1978 On Site55days
On A Beautiful Rolling Acre W/Pond & Waterviews, This 3 Br/2 Ba Home Has Lovely Extras Including A New Chef's Kitchen W/Island, Stainless Appliances, Formal Dining Room, Living... more
On A Beautiful Rolling Acre W/Pond & Waterviews, This 3 Br/2 Ba Home Has Lovely Extras Including A New Chef's Kitchen W/Island, Stainless Appliances, Formal Dining Room, Living Room W/Sliders To A Spacious Waterside Deck, Master Bedroom W/Private Bath, Gas Fireplace & Hot Tub Room, Custom Fenced Garden, Plus A Finished Basement & Game Room W/Wood Stove. A Must See! less
Listing Provided Courtesy of DANIEL GALE SOTHEBYS INTL RLTY
Popularity
$920,000
$3,255/mo
Monthly Payment:
$3,255
Principal & Interest:
$3,255
HOA Dues:
$0
(Based on a 30 year fixed loan at 3.38% with $184,000 down)
Shelter Island, NY 11964
Shelter Island Union Free School District
3bed 2bath 1,660sq ft $554 / sq ft SFR
Lot Size28,314sq ft Built1959 On Site69days
109' Waterfront On 'Fresh Pond' With Spans Of Glass To Enjoy Stunning Sunsets On A Daily Basis. Spacious Second Floor Master Suite W/2 -1st Floor Guest Bedrooms. Water-Views... more
109' Waterfront On 'Fresh Pond' With Spans Of Glass To Enjoy Stunning Sunsets On A Daily Basis. Spacious Second Floor Master Suite W/2 -1st Floor Guest Bedrooms. Water-Views Throughout The Open Floor Plan With A Waterside Elevated Deck For Entertaining Or Peaceful Enjoyment Of Nature. Wades Beach Just Down The Street. Co-Exclusive. less
Listing Provided Courtesy of DANIEL GALE SOTHEBYS INTL RLTY
Popularity
$1,149,000
$4,066/mo
Monthly Payment:
$4,066
Principal & Interest:
$4,066
HOA Dues:
$0
(Based on a 30 year fixed loan at 3.38% with $229,800 down)
Shelter Island, NY 11964
Shelter Island Union Free School District
2bed 1bath 1,200sq ft $958 / sq ft SFR
Lot Size1.9acre Built1965 On Site82days
This Listing Is A Very Rare Find Because The Property Has Front Yard And Backyard Water Views On 1.7 Acres Along With A Beach Lot That Is 25Ft Wide X Approx. 118Ft Long Located... more
This Listing Is A Very Rare Find Because The Property Has Front Yard And Backyard Water Views On 1.7 Acres Along With A Beach Lot That Is 25Ft Wide X Approx. 118Ft Long Located On Peconic Ave. less
Listing Provided Courtesy of DOUGLAS ELLIMAN REAL ESTATE
Popularity
$879,000
$3,110/mo
Monthly Payment:
$3,110
Principal & Interest:
$3,110
HOA Dues:
$0
(Based on a 30 year fixed loan at 3.38% with $175,800 down)
Shelter Island, NY 11964
Shelter Island Union Free School District
3bed 3bath 2,750sq ft $320 / sq ft SFR
Lot Size37,897sq ft Built1990 On Site104days
Reduced To Below Assessed Value! Mint Island Oasis Ready For You To Enjoy Year Round. Entry Foyer W/Granite Floors, Formal Living Room, Family Room W/Fp & 2 Skylights, Dr, Eik... more
Reduced To Below Assessed Value! Mint Island Oasis Ready For You To Enjoy Year Round. Entry Foyer W/Granite Floors, Formal Living Room, Family Room W/Fp & 2 Skylights, Dr, Eik W/Island. 1st Floor Master Suite W/Jacuzzi & Sep Shower. Laundry, .5Ba, 2 Car Garage & Decks Across The Back For Entertaining. 2nd Floor W/2 Large Bedrooms & Full Ba. Room For A Pool And More! less
Listing Provided Courtesy of DANIEL GALE SOTHEBYS INTL RLTY
Popularity
$850,000
$3,008/mo
Monthly Payment:
$3,008
Principal & Interest:
$3,008
HOA Dues:
$0
(Based on a 30 year fixed loan at 3.38% with $170,000 down)
Shelter Island, NY 11964
Shelter Island Union Free School District
3bed 2bath 1,496sq ft $568 / sq ft SFR
Lot Size27,443sq ft Built1967 On Site124days
Open Sat May 7, 12pm-2pm
Craftsman-Quality Ranch In Desirable Silver Beach, Just Houses From Peconic Bay Beaches. Beautiful Hardwood Floors, Water Views And Open Concept. Private And Well Landscaped... more
Craftsman-Quality Ranch In Desirable Silver Beach, Just Houses From Peconic Bay Beaches. Beautiful Hardwood Floors, Water Views And Open Concept. Private And Well Landscaped Backyard With Spacious Decks Overlooking In-Ground Pool. less
Listing Provided Courtesy of TOWN AND COUNTRY REAL ESTATE
Popularity
ZipRealty helps you find current homes for sale in Shelter Island, NY. We show up to 30% more MLS listings than other websites, including new homes for sale, condos for sale, townhomes for sale, foreclosed homes for sale and land for sale. Set up your unique Shelter Island real estate search criteria to see results that match what you're looking for. Explore maps, photos, schools and more to get an idea of what your life would be like in a new neighborhood. Find a local Shelter Island real estate agent to work with by reading realtor reviews left by buyers and sellers like you. If you want to know what your home is worth, you can instantly view home values for any address by visiting our Seller Center. If you're planning to sell your home, you can also see how much similar homes are selling for in Shelter Island to get an idea of how to price your home.
Local real estate services provided by:
Century 21 American Homes
Century 21 American Homes
1856 Hempstead Turnpike
East Meadow, NY 11554

855.875.8640
Website provided and owned by Century 21 American Homes.
 
Follow Us On
Loading....
Loading
The information being provided by Long Island MLS is for the consumer's personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumer may be interested in purchasing. Any information relating to real estate for sale referenced on this web site comes from the Internet Data Exchange (IDX) program of the Long Island MLS. Merrick Century LLC dba Century 21 American Homes is not a Multiple Listing Service (MLS), nor does it offer MLS access. This website is a service of Merrick Century LLC dba Century 21 American Homes, a broker participant of Long Island MLS. This web site may reference real estate listing(s) held by a brokerage firm other than the broker and/or agent who owns this web site.

The accuracy of all information, regardless of source, including but not limited to open house information, square footages and lot sizes, is deemed reliable but not guaranteed and should be personally verified through personal inspection by and/or with the appropriate professionals. The data contained herein is copyrighted by Long Island MLS and is protected by all applicable copyright laws. Any unauthorized dissemination of this information is in violation of copyright laws and is strictly prohibited.

Copyright 2016 Long Island MLS. All rights reserved.

Data last updated: Monday, May 2, 2016 at 7:48 PM. Properties in listings may have been sold or may no longer be available.