Call your local brokerage at 855.875.8640

Shelter Island Real Estate — Homes For Sale in Shelter Island, NY

32 Properties Found [ Edit Search ]
Save This Search
Receive Email Alerts
First page 1 of 3 Last
$990,000

1 Locust Woods Dr

Shelter Island, NY 11964
Shelter Island Union Free School District
4bed 3bath 2,275sq ft $435 / sq ft SFR
Lot Size1.9acre Built1997 On ZipRealty14 days
Adjacent To 11 Acre Preserve, This Well Maintained 4 Bedroom 3 Bath Traditional Is Well Sited On 1.9 Landscaped Acres. With Covered Frt Porch + Sunny Back Deck. Natural Light... more
Adjacent To 11 Acre Preserve, This Well Maintained 4 Bedroom 3 Bath Traditional Is Well Sited On 1.9 Landscaped Acres. With Covered Frt Porch + Sunny Back Deck. Natural Light Fills The Stainless Eik Which Overlooks Lvr W/Fireplace. Office/Den/Art Studio Is Easily Accessed From The Eik By Private Staircase. This Gracious Property Has Plenty Of Room For Tennis And Pool. less
Listing Provided Courtesy of Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty
Popularity N/A
We show you up to 30% more homes than other sites. Learn more.
$785,000

8 Bayshore Dr

Shelter Island, NY 11964
Shelter Island Union Free School District
3bed 2bath 1,902sq ft $413 / sq ft SFR
Lot Size40,075sq ft Built1985 On ZipRealty20 days
The Board And Batten Captains House Is Very Close To Water Access And Ass'n Beaches With 3 Bedrooms, 2 Baths, Spacious Living Room With Mason Built Fireplace And Eat In Kitchen... more
The Board And Batten Captains House Is Very Close To Water Access And Ass'n Beaches With 3 Bedrooms, 2 Baths, Spacious Living Room With Mason Built Fireplace And Eat In Kitchen With Full Butler's Pantry/Laundry, Generous Sunroom And Bedroom Or Office And Full Bath On 1st Floor. Upstairs Are Two Roomy Bedrooms And Full Bath. The Barn Is Perfect For Storing Boats Or Studio. less
Listing Provided Courtesy of Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty
Popularity N/A
$1,675,000

100 S Midway Rd

Shelter Island, NY 11964
Shelter Island Union Free School District
4bed 3bath 2,260sq ft $741 / sq ft SFR
Lot Size40,946sq ft Built1986 On ZipRealty21 days
Stroll To Wades Beach From This Beautifully Renovated Modern Home. With Sun Drenched Exposures, White Washed Walls, And Palette Of Soft Blues And Greens, This Home Beckons As An... more
Stroll To Wades Beach From This Beautifully Renovated Modern Home. With Sun Drenched Exposures, White Washed Walls, And Palette Of Soft Blues And Greens, This Home Beckons As An Island Retreat. 4 Bedrooms, 3 Baths, Bright & Airy Summer Or Year Round Home With Heated Gunite Pool And Water View. New To The Market, An Ideal Island Get-Away! Move In Ready less
Listing Provided Courtesy of Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty
Popularity N/A
$1,975,000

67 Gardiners Bay Dr

Shelter Island, NY 11964
Shelter Island Union Free School District
6bed 4bath 3,717sq ft $531 / sq ft SFR
Lot Size39,640sq ft Built1973 On ZipRealty27 days
Quintessential Turn Key, Waterview New England Traditional Compound Is Also A Cozy Cottage For Quiet Restorative Holidays. Pool, Mature Gardens, New Marble Chef's Eat In Kitchen... more
Quintessential Turn Key, Waterview New England Traditional Compound Is Also A Cozy Cottage For Quiet Restorative Holidays. Pool, Mature Gardens, New Marble Chef's Eat In Kitchen W/ Keeper's Room + Fpl, Formal Dining Room + Waterview Deck, Elegant Lr + Fpl, Sunny Windowed Cathedral Ceiling Den, Master Suite Has Office Just Outside. A Rare Find Across From Private Beach less
Listing Provided Courtesy of Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty
Popularity N/A
$759,000

16 Sylvan Rd

Shelter Island, NY 11964
Shelter Island Union Free School District
3bed 2bath 1,247sq ft $609 / sq ft SFR
Lot Size37,462sq ft Built1976 On ZipRealty39 days
This Lovely .86 Acre Parcel Is Situated On A Quiet Cul-De-Sac. This Renovated Home Offers A Living Room With Vaulted Ceiling, Wood Burning Fireplace, Wood Floors. There Are... more
This Lovely .86 Acre Parcel Is Situated On A Quiet Cul-De-Sac. This Renovated Home Offers A Living Room With Vaulted Ceiling, Wood Burning Fireplace, Wood Floors. There Are Beautiful Outdoor Entertaining Areas Both On The Wood Deck And Pool Side. The Hot Tub Spills Into Your Own 20 X 40 Gunite Heated Pool With Cabana And Outdoor Shower. Lovely, Private,Lush Yard. less
Listing Provided Courtesy of Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty
Popularity N/A
$239,000

11 Johnston Rd

Shelter Island, NY 11964
Shelter Island Union Free School District
N/Asq ft N/A / sq ft LND
Lot Size26,136sq ft BuiltN/A On ZipRealty51 days
Level .60 acre lot on a very quiet street. Create your island oasis in this remarkable and peaceful location. Near mini golf and area beaches this lot is priced to sell.... more
Level .60 acre lot on a very quiet street. Create your island oasis in this remarkable and peaceful location. Near mini golf and area beaches this lot is priced to sell. Neighboring property also available for purchase. less
Listing Provided Courtesy of Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty
Popularity N/A
$2,999,000

47 Peconic Ave

Shelter Island, NY 11964
Shelter Island Union Free School District
3bed 4bath 3,137sq ft $956 / sq ft SFR
Lot Size27,007sq ft Built1970 On ZipRealty65 days
Beautiful Sunsets From This Waterview Compound. The Main 3+ En Suite Bedroom Shingle Traditional With Pool Is Landscaped With Mature Plantings. There Is Also Sandy Beachfront... more
Beautiful Sunsets From This Waterview Compound. The Main 3+ En Suite Bedroom Shingle Traditional With Pool Is Landscaped With Mature Plantings. There Is Also Sandy Beachfront Property + An Adjacent Wv Lot That Make Up This Move In Ready Bucolic Retreat With Many High End Extras Including Waterside Roof Gazebo, Den + Additional Parlor. less
Listing Provided Courtesy of Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty
Popularity N/A
$650,000

3 Peppermill Ln

Shelter Island, NY 11964
Shelter Island Union Free School District
3bed 2bath 1,361sq ft $478 / sq ft SFR
Lot Size40,075sq ft Built1986 On ZipRealty66 days
On A Quiet + Lovely Cul-De-Sac With A Detached 550 Sq Ft Artist Studio This 3 Bedroom, 2 Baths, Ranch Sits On .92Acres. Entering The House You Are Greeted By An Open Living Area... more
On A Quiet + Lovely Cul-De-Sac With A Detached 550 Sq Ft Artist Studio This 3 Bedroom, 2 Baths, Ranch Sits On .92Acres. Entering The House You Are Greeted By An Open Living Area W Fireplace, Dining, Kitchen + Sliding Doors To Deck. Access To Full Basemnt From In +Outside. Room For Pool! less
Listing Provided Courtesy of Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty
Popularity N/A
$499,000

9 Johnston Rd

Shelter Island, NY 11964
Shelter Island Union Free School District
4bed 2bath 1,344sq ft $371 / sq ft SFR
Lot Size26,136sq ft Built1965 On ZipRealty74 days
Adorable 4Br/2Ba In Peaceful Setting. Listen To The Birds As You Enter This Scenic .6 Acre Property. Large Basement Includes 1+ Car Garage And Two More Rooms. Easy To Show!
Adorable 4Br/2Ba In Peaceful Setting. Listen To The Birds As You Enter This Scenic .6 Acre Property. Large Basement Includes 1+ Car Garage And Two More Rooms. Easy To Show! less
Listing Provided Courtesy of Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty
Popularity N/A
$999,000

39 S Midway Rd

Shelter Island, NY 11964
Shelter Island Union Free School District
4bed 3bath 2,200sq ft $454 / sq ft SFR
Lot Size1.3acre Built1954 On ZipRealty80 days
Scenic 4Br/3Ba Contemporary With 170 Feet Of Water Frontage On A Large Freshwater Lake . 1.2 Spacious Acres With Room For A Waterside Pool. 10 Skylights Keep This Home Bright... more
Scenic 4Br/3Ba Contemporary With 170 Feet Of Water Frontage On A Large Freshwater Lake . 1.2 Spacious Acres With Room For A Waterside Pool. 10 Skylights Keep This Home Bright And Open. less
Listing Provided Courtesy of Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty
Popularity N/A
$399,000

9 Margarets Dr

Shelter Island, NY 11964
Shelter Island Union Free School District
N/Asq ft N/A / sq ft LND
Lot Size39,640sq ft BuiltN/A On ZipRealty89 days
Lovely Shy Acre In West Wind Knolls On A Road That Is Less Traveled! The U Shaped Street Does Not Get Through Traffic And Is Away From The Hustle And Bustle. The Property Is A... more
Lovely Shy Acre In West Wind Knolls On A Road That Is Less Traveled! The U Shaped Street Does Not Get Through Traffic And Is Away From The Hustle And Bustle. The Property Is A Canvas Where A Dream House Can Be Created. West Wind Knolls Association Has Its Own Private Right Of Way For Access To Swimming Or Kayaking Or Boating On West Neck Creek. It Is A Desirable Location. less
Listing Provided Courtesy of Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty
Popularity N/A
$3,280,000

8c Pheasant Ln

Shelter Island, NY 11964
Shelter Island Union Free School District
4bed 4bath 2,304sq ft $1,424 / sq ft SFR
Lot Size29,185sq ft Built1984 On ZipRealty89 days
Artistically Hand Crafted Waterfront Retreat, 4 Bedrooms, 3.5 Baths, Waterside Roof Deck, Gunite Pool, Water's Edge Deck, Bulkhead, Deep Water Dock + Lift, Sandy Beach,... more
Artistically Hand Crafted Waterfront Retreat, 4 Bedrooms, 3.5 Baths, Waterside Roof Deck, Gunite Pool, Water's Edge Deck, Bulkhead, Deep Water Dock + Lift, Sandy Beach, Magnificent Waterviews + Sunsets. Made Of Steel, Corrugated Metal + Concrete, Floored In 1' Sq Mexican Tile; Half Barrel Roof, Half Court Basketball Court, Bocci Court + Private Sculptural Gardens Surround less
Listing Provided Courtesy of Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty
Popularity N/A
Stoneleigh Subdivision, Comprised Of Four Individual Lots Being Sold As A Package Totaling 4.7 Acres. Utilities And Road Are In Place. Addresses: 56A, 56B, 58 & 60 North... more
Stoneleigh Subdivision, Comprised Of Four Individual Lots Being Sold As A Package Totaling 4.7 Acres. Utilities And Road Are In Place. Addresses: 56A, 56B, 58 & 60 North Menantic Road, Tax Map Locations: 14.-351.10, 51.11, 51.12 & 51.13. less
Listing Provided Courtesy of Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty
Popularity N/A
Beautiful Parcel On A Cul-De-Sac On A Quiet Street. Lots Of Potential With Room For A Swimming Pool And/Or A Tennis Court. This Flag Lot Will Provide Privacy In One Of The Most... more
Beautiful Parcel On A Cul-De-Sac On A Quiet Street. Lots Of Potential With Room For A Swimming Pool And/Or A Tennis Court. This Flag Lot Will Provide Privacy In One Of The Most Desireable Areas Of Shelter Island. less
Listing Provided Courtesy of Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty
Popularity N/A
$210,000

57 F Strobel Rd

Shelter Island, NY 11964
Shelter Island Union Free School District
N/Asq ft N/A / sq ft LND
Lot Size16,117sq ft BuiltN/A On ZipRealty101 days
Small, Buildable Lot, Near Beaches, Golf & Restaurants, This Property Is Nestled Down A Private Lane. Build Your Dream Home Here, Surrounded By Nature.
Small, Buildable Lot, Near Beaches, Golf & Restaurants, This Property Is Nestled Down A Private Lane. Build Your Dream Home Here, Surrounded By Nature. less
Listing Provided Courtesy of Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty
Popularity N/A
ZipRealty helps you find current homes for sale in Shelter Island, NY. We show up to 30% more MLS listings than other websites, including new homes for sale, condos for sale, townhomes for sale, foreclosed homes for sale and land for sale. Set up your unique Shelter Island real estate search criteria to see results that match what you're looking for. Explore maps, photos, schools and more to get an idea of what your life would be like in a new neighborhood. Find a local Shelter Island real estate agent to work with by reading realtor reviews left by buyers and sellers like you. If you want to know what your home is worth, you can instantly view home values for any address by visiting our Seller Center. If you're planning to sell your home, you can also see how much similar homes are selling for in Shelter Island to get an idea of how to price your home.
Local real estate services provided by:
Century 21 American Homes
Century 21 American Homes
1856 Hempstead Turnpike
East Meadow, NY 11554
855.875.8640
Website owned and operated by ZipRealty, Inc.
Please contact us with any technical
issues or questions about our services.
1.800.225.5947
Local service is provided by our preferred broker, Century 21 American Homes. By logging on to ziprealty.com, you are authorizing ZipRealty to refer you to Century 21 American Homes for real estate brokerage services, and ZipRealty will receive a referral fee or other valuable consideration for such referral.
Loading....
Loading
The information being provided by Long Island MLS is for the consumer's personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumer may be interested in purchasing. Any information relating to real estate for sale referenced on this web site comes from the Internet Data Exchange (IDX) program of the Long Island MLS. Century 21 American Homes is not a Multiple Listing Service (MLS), nor does it offer MLS access. This website is a service of Century 21 American Homes, a broker participant of Long Island MLS. This web site may reference real estate listing(s) held by a brokerage firm other than the broker and/or agent who owns this web site.

The accuracy of all information, regardless of source, including but not limited to open house information, square footages and lot sizes, is deemed reliable but not guaranteed and should be personally verified through personal inspection by and/or with the appropriate professionals. The data contained herein is copyrighted by Long Island MLS and is protected by all applicable copyright laws. Any unauthorized dissemination of this information is in violation of copyright laws and is strictly prohibited.

Copyright 2014 Long Island MLS. All rights reserved.

Data last updated: Thursday, August 28, 2014 at 8:03 AM