Call your local brokerage at 855.875.8640

Shelter Island, NY Real Estate — Homes For Sale in Shelter Island, NY

33 Properties Found [ Edit Search ]
Save This Search
Receive Email Alerts
First page 1 of 3 Last
$1,375,000
$5,245/mo
Monthly Payment:
$5,245
Principal & Interest:
$5,245
HOA Dues:
$0
(Based on a 30 year fixed loan at 3.99% with $275,000 down)
Shelter Island, NY 11964
Shelter Island Union Free School District
4bed 4bath 3,410sq ft $403 / sq ft SFR
Lot Size1.9acre Built2000 On Site7days
Exceptional Estate On Private 1.9 Acre Property, Across Fr Sylvester Manor Preserved Farmlands W/ Pool & Room For Tennis. Kitchen W/Breakfast Rm & Fam Rm W/Fp Leads To Outdr... more
Exceptional Estate On Private 1.9 Acre Property, Across Fr Sylvester Manor Preserved Farmlands W/ Pool & Room For Tennis. Kitchen W/Breakfast Rm & Fam Rm W/Fp Leads To Outdr Dining & Poolside Patio. 1st Fl Mbr Suite, 2nd Fl 2 Roomy Brs & Lge Office/Den/Or 3rd Br. Lower Level Fnshd Rm Great For Office/Studio Or Game Rm. Detached 3 Car Garage W/ 1 Br Apt Above. less
Listing Provided Courtesy of Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty
Popularity
Your search results are current and complete. Learn more
$595,000
$2,269/mo
Monthly Payment:
$2,269
Principal & Interest:
$2,269
HOA Dues:
$0
(Based on a 30 year fixed loan at 3.99% with $119,000 down)
Shelter Island, NY 11964
Shelter Island Union Free School District
2bed 2bath 1,230sq ft $484 / sq ft SFR
Lot Size24,394sq ft Built1938 On Site8days
Charming Cottage In A Location That Is Close To The Center, The Marina And Hampshire Farms. The Property Has Excellent Potential For Expansion. The Well Was Installed In 2009;... more
Charming Cottage In A Location That Is Close To The Center, The Marina And Hampshire Farms. The Property Has Excellent Potential For Expansion. The Well Was Installed In 2009; The Septic Is In Place And Can Accommodate Up To Six Bedrooms. Plans Are Drawn For A Separate House On The Same Lot For 2000-2500Sq.Feet. A Great Place To Enjoy The Beauty That Is Shelter Island less
Listing Provided Courtesy of Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty
Popularity
$1,199,000
$4,573/mo
Monthly Payment:
$4,573
Principal & Interest:
$4,573
HOA Dues:
$0
(Based on a 30 year fixed loan at 3.99% with $239,800 down)
Shelter Island, NY 11964
Shelter Island Union Free School District
4bed 3bath 2,157sq ft $556 / sq ft SFR
Lot Size1.1acre Built1981 On Site9days
Totally Renovated And Expanded 4 Bedroom Ranch. New Windows, New Roof, And New Hardie Board Siding, New Kitchen With S/S Appliances. New Bathrooms And A New 500 Sq. Ft. En-Suite... more
Totally Renovated And Expanded 4 Bedroom Ranch. New Windows, New Roof, And New Hardie Board Siding, New Kitchen With S/S Appliances. New Bathrooms And A New 500 Sq. Ft. En-Suite Master Bedroom Overlooking New In-Ground Heated Pool. Newly Landscaped Property In Lovely Residential Area Just Minutes From Beach. less
Listing Provided Courtesy of Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty
Popularity
$489,000
$1,865/mo
Monthly Payment:
$1,865
Principal & Interest:
$1,865
HOA Dues:
$0
(Based on a 30 year fixed loan at 3.99% with $97,800 down)
Shelter Island, NY 11964
Shelter Island Union Free School District
2bed 1bath 925sq ft $529 / sq ft SFR
Lot Size20,038sq ft Built1940 On Site16days
Move In To This Newly Renovated Island Cottage. Vaulted Ceilings, Air Conditioning, New Decks, Driveway, Fencing, Washer/Dryer And Outdoor Shower Among Others. Comfortable, Cozy... more
Move In To This Newly Renovated Island Cottage. Vaulted Ceilings, Air Conditioning, New Decks, Driveway, Fencing, Washer/Dryer And Outdoor Shower Among Others. Comfortable, Cozy And Centrally Located, A Short Bike Ride To Beaches, Town Center, Restaurants And Golf. A Large New Deck Allows You To Enjoy The Beautiful & Spacious Back Yard. Ready For Your Summer Fun! less
Listing Provided Courtesy of Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty
Popularity
$1,300,000
$4,959/mo
Monthly Payment:
$4,959
Principal & Interest:
$4,959
HOA Dues:
$0
(Based on a 30 year fixed loan at 3.99% with $260,000 down)
Shelter Island, NY 11964
Shelter Island Union Free School District
2bed 1bath 1,370sq ft $949 / sq ft SFR
Lot Size1.7acre Built1965 On Site18days
Shy Two Acre Waterfront Property In Silver Beach On Shelter Island. Two Bedroom, Two Bath Home With Water Views From First Floor. Sweeping, Unobstructed Southwest Views To... more
Shy Two Acre Waterfront Property In Silver Beach On Shelter Island. Two Bedroom, Two Bath Home With Water Views From First Floor. Sweeping, Unobstructed Southwest Views To Jessup Neck And Peconic Bay. Fireplace, Wood Floors, Deck. Direct Deeded Beach Access. Boat Ramp Nearby. Preserve As Is Or Build Out. less
Listing Provided Courtesy of Re/max Signature Real Estate
Popularity
$975,000
$3,719/mo
Monthly Payment:
$3,719
Principal & Interest:
$3,719
HOA Dues:
$0
(Based on a 30 year fixed loan at 3.99% with $195,000 down)
Shelter Island, NY 11964
Shelter Island Union Free School District
3bed 3bath 1,753sq ft $556 / sq ft SFR
Lot Size1.3acre Built1995 On Site20days
As You Enter This Home You Notice The Double Height Ceilings, Sun Lit Rooms And Open Floor Plan Which Is Ideal For Entertaining. The Cedar Room Allows For Relaxation And Comfort... more
As You Enter This Home You Notice The Double Height Ceilings, Sun Lit Rooms And Open Floor Plan Which Is Ideal For Entertaining. The Cedar Room Allows For Relaxation And Comfort While Watching Nature. The Large Mast Suite On The Second Floor Has Its Own Balcony Overlooking The Backyard. Located Just Blocks From Crescent Beach. less
Listing Provided Courtesy of Douglas Elliman Real Estate
Popularity
$2,695,000
$10,280/mo
Monthly Payment:
$10,280
Principal & Interest:
$10,280
HOA Dues:
$0
(Based on a 30 year fixed loan at 3.99% with $539,000 down)
Shelter Island, NY 11964
Shelter Island Union Free School District
4bed 5bath 2,774sq ft $972 / sq ft SFR
Lot Size1.0acre Built2012 On Site22days
Finally A Turn Key Exceptionally Built, Spacious, Light Filled, Waterfront Shingle Traditional With Pool + Dock In Quiet Private Community. Beautiful Waterviews! Also Boasts 2... more
Finally A Turn Key Exceptionally Built, Spacious, Light Filled, Waterfront Shingle Traditional With Pool + Dock In Quiet Private Community. Beautiful Waterviews! Also Boasts 2 Waterside Master Suites Each With Waterside Decks. Open Floor Plan With Excellent Investment And Residential Opportunities. Separate Carriage House Has Loft And Grounds Are Landscaped For Privacy. less
Listing Provided Courtesy of Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty
Popularity
$650,000
$2,479/mo
Monthly Payment:
$2,479
Principal & Interest:
$2,479
HOA Dues:
$0
(Based on a 30 year fixed loan at 3.99% with $130,000 down)
Shelter Island, NY 11964
Shelter Island Union Free School District
3bed 2bath 1,533sq ft $424 / sq ft SFR
Lot Size20,038sq ft Built1966 On Site36days
Excellent Location On A Private Cul-De-Sac, This Property Boasts A Strip Along West Neck Creek For Kayaks Or Boating Or Even Som Beach Chairs To Enjoy The Sunsets. Great For... more
Excellent Location On A Private Cul-De-Sac, This Property Boasts A Strip Along West Neck Creek For Kayaks Or Boating Or Even Som Beach Chairs To Enjoy The Sunsets. Great For Summer Sports, Biking And Jogging; It Is Near To The Center And The Marina. The House Has Been Lovingly Maintained And Has Many Extras Such As Newly Done Floors And A New Oil Burner. Great Potential! less
Listing Provided Courtesy of Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty
Popularity
$595,000
$2,269/mo
Monthly Payment:
$2,269
Principal & Interest:
$2,269
HOA Dues:
$0
(Based on a 30 year fixed loan at 3.99% with $119,000 down)
Shelter Island, NY 11964
Shelter Island Union Free School District
N/Asq ft N/A / sq ft LND
Lot Size1.1acre BuiltN/A On Site38days
Located In The Shorewood Section Of Shelter Island, This Unique 1.2 Acre Property Has A View Of A Beautiful Creek ( Mabel's ) And A Pond That Is Located Towards The Backside Of... more
Located In The Shorewood Section Of Shelter Island, This Unique 1.2 Acre Property Has A View Of A Beautiful Creek ( Mabel's ) And A Pond That Is Located Towards The Backside Of The Property. There Is A Home Located On The Property But It's Not In Livable Condition At This Time. less
Listing Provided Courtesy of Douglas Elliman Real Estate
Popularity
$869,990
$3,318/mo
Monthly Payment:
$3,318
Principal & Interest:
$3,318
HOA Dues:
$0
(Based on a 30 year fixed loan at 3.99% with $173,998 down)
Shelter Island, NY 11964
Shelter Island Union Free School District
4bed 3bath N/Asq ft N/A / sq ft SFR
Lot Size2,272sq ft Built1983 On Site39days
A 4 bedroom, 2.5 bath charm nestled in a quiet shelter island neighborhood. Features an eat-in kitchen, formal dining room gives way to a beautiful, private sunroom. Expanded... more
A 4 bedroom, 2.5 bath charm nestled in a quiet shelter island neighborhood. Features an eat-in kitchen, formal dining room gives way to a beautiful, private sunroom. Expanded living area, full basement. All on 1.2 acres complete with a 16x32 in-ground pool and screened in gazebo with electrical hookup. Detached spacious two-car garage and circular driveway. less
Listing Provided Courtesy of Coldwell Banker Beau Hulse Rlt
Popularity
$1,550,000
$5,912/mo
Monthly Payment:
$5,912
Principal & Interest:
$5,912
HOA Dues:
$0
(Based on a 30 year fixed loan at 3.99% with $310,000 down)
Shelter Island, NY 11964
Shelter Island Union Free School District
N/Asq ft N/A / sq ft LND
Lot Size4.7acre BuiltN/A On Site42days
Stoneleigh Subdivision, Comprised Of Four Individual Lots Being Sold As A Package Totaling 4.7 Acres. Utilities And Road Are In Place. Addresses: 56A, 56B, 58 & 60 North... more
Stoneleigh Subdivision, Comprised Of Four Individual Lots Being Sold As A Package Totaling 4.7 Acres. Utilities And Road Are In Place. Addresses: 56A, 56B, 58 & 60 North Menantic Road. Tax Map Locations: 14.-3 51.10, 51.11, 51.12 & 51.13. less
Listing Provided Courtesy of Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty
Popularity
$425,000
$1,621/mo
Monthly Payment:
$1,621
Principal & Interest:
$1,621
HOA Dues:
$0
(Based on a 30 year fixed loan at 3.99% with $85,000 down)
Shelter Island, NY 11964
Shelter Island Union Free School District
3bed 1bath 612sq ft $694 / sq ft SFR
Lot Size21,780sq ft Built1938 On Site44days
Wonderful Cottage With Screened In Porch For Summer Or Year Round Enjoyment. Backs Up To Preserve With Trails And Room For A Pool. Appliances And Heating Updated Within Last 5... more
Wonderful Cottage With Screened In Porch For Summer Or Year Round Enjoyment. Backs Up To Preserve With Trails And Room For A Pool. Appliances And Heating Updated Within Last 5 Years. Newly Renovated But Holds Much Of Its 1938 Charm. less
Listing Provided Courtesy of Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty
Popularity
$2,299,000
$8,770/mo
Monthly Payment:
$8,770
Principal & Interest:
$8,770
HOA Dues:
$0
(Based on a 30 year fixed loan at 3.99% with $459,800 down)
Shelter Island, NY 11964
Shelter Island Union Free School District
3bed 3bath 2,800sq ft $821 / sq ft SFR
Lot Size1.1acre Built1950 On Site56days
This 3 Bd.Rm,3 Bath Bayfront Is Situated On 1.11Ac Of Meticulously Landscpd Parcel W/140'Dock & 100Amp Of Shore Power. It Features A New Kit,10 Seat Media Rm,Full Bar... more
This 3 Bd.Rm,3 Bath Bayfront Is Situated On 1.11Ac Of Meticulously Landscpd Parcel W/140'Dock & 100Amp Of Shore Power. It Features A New Kit,10 Seat Media Rm,Full Bar Area,Climate Controlled Wine Cellar W/Tasting Area, Whole House Back Up Generator & Secluded/Heated Igpool Area W/Stone Patio. This One-Of-A-Kind Home Is Truly Unique To The Area! less
Listing Provided Courtesy of Realty Connect Usa Llc
Popularity
$770,000
$2,937/mo
Monthly Payment:
$2,937
Principal & Interest:
$2,937
HOA Dues:
$0
(Based on a 30 year fixed loan at 3.99% with $154,000 down)
Shelter Island, NY 11964
Shelter Island Union Free School District
3bed 3bath 1,580sq ft $487 / sq ft SFR
Lot Size40,075sq ft Built2013 On Site98days
Rare Turn Key Sleek Modern Has Walls Of Windows To Let In Great Light; See Sunrise + Sunset From Either Side. Chef's Granite + Stainless Kitchen + Island Has Door To Dining Deck... more
Rare Turn Key Sleek Modern Has Walls Of Windows To Let In Great Light; See Sunrise + Sunset From Either Side. Chef's Granite + Stainless Kitchen + Island Has Door To Dining Deck + Is Open To Dining Room + Living Room With Fireplace. Owners Suite On 1st Floor Opens To Deck. Both Guest Rooms On Second Floor Have Decks, One With Waterview, Short Blocks To Beach + Resorts. less
Listing Provided Courtesy of Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty
Popularity
$1,300,000
$4,959/mo
Monthly Payment:
$4,959
Principal & Interest:
$4,959
HOA Dues:
$0
(Based on a 30 year fixed loan at 3.99% with $260,000 down)
Shelter Island, NY 11964
Shelter Island Union Free School District
2bed 2bath 1,370sq ft $949 / sq ft SFR
Lot Size1.7acre Built1965 On Site107days
Shy Two Acre Waterfront Property In Silver Beach On Shelter Island. Two Bedroom, Two Bath Home With Water Views From First Floor. Sweeping, Unobstructed Southwest Views To... more
Shy Two Acre Waterfront Property In Silver Beach On Shelter Island. Two Bedroom, Two Bath Home With Water Views From First Floor. Sweeping, Unobstructed Southwest Views To Jessup Neck And Peconic Bay. Fireplace, Wood Floors, Deck. Direct Deeded Beach Access. Boat Ramp Nearby. Preserve As Is Or Build Out. less
Listing Provided Courtesy of Nest Seekers International Llc
Popularity
ZipRealty helps you find current homes for sale in Shelter Island, NY. We show up to 30% more MLS listings than other websites, including new homes for sale, condos for sale, townhomes for sale, foreclosed homes for sale and land for sale. Set up your unique Shelter Island real estate search criteria to see results that match what you're looking for. Explore maps, photos, schools and more to get an idea of what your life would be like in a new neighborhood. Find a local Shelter Island real estate agent to work with by reading realtor reviews left by buyers and sellers like you. If you want to know what your home is worth, you can instantly view home values for any address by visiting our Seller Center. If you're planning to sell your home, you can also see how much similar homes are selling for in Shelter Island to get an idea of how to price your home.
Local real estate services provided by:
Century 21 American Homes
Century 21 American Homes
1856 Hempstead Turnpike
East Meadow, NY 11554
855.875.8640
Content provided and owned by Century 21 American Homes.
Loading....
Loading
The information being provided by Long Island MLS is for the consumer's personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumer may be interested in purchasing. Any information relating to real estate for sale referenced on this web site comes from the Internet Data Exchange (IDX) program of the Long Island MLS. Merrick Century LLC dba Century 21 American Homes is not a Multiple Listing Service (MLS), nor does it offer MLS access. This website is a service of Merrick Century LLC dba Century 21 American Homes, a broker participant of Long Island MLS. This web site may reference real estate listing(s) held by a brokerage firm other than the broker and/or agent who owns this web site.

The accuracy of all information, regardless of source, including but not limited to open house information, square footages and lot sizes, is deemed reliable but not guaranteed and should be personally verified through personal inspection by and/or with the appropriate professionals. The data contained herein is copyrighted by Long Island MLS and is protected by all applicable copyright laws. Any unauthorized dissemination of this information is in violation of copyright laws and is strictly prohibited.

Copyright 2015 Long Island MLS. All rights reserved.

Data last updated: Monday, May 4, 2015 at 7:54 PM