Call your local brokerage at 1.800.225.5947
Reset Search
Price from
 to Beds Baths More Search Options
Add Cities
Available Cities
    Your Selected Cities
      Minimum Sq. Ft.
      Minimum Lot Size
      to Year Built
      Days listed
      Property Type
      Single Family
      Land
      Condo/Townhouse
      Multi-Family


      Listing features
      Listing type
      Show Additional Property Features


      Deck
      Patio


      Carport
      Garage

      Parking Spaces:

      Electric
      Gas
      Oil


      Central
      Wall Unit
      Window

      # of stories:

      Foundation:
      Siding:

      Architectural Style:

      Shelter Island Real Estate — Homes For Sale in Shelter Island, NY

      27 Properties Found [ Edit Search ] Save This Search

      Resource Center

      Sponsored
      View:
      Showing 1-15.
      page 1 of 2 | Last
      Home Photo
      4 Photos

      0 br 0 ba Land N/A sq ft N/A/sq ft 21,780 sq. ft. lot Built: N/A On ZipRealty 13 days Map

      Perfect Place For A New Year-Round Or Vacation Residence. This Is A Vacant Lot. Owner Will... more
      Save Ask Visit Share
      Listing Provided Courtesy of Long Island Horse Properties Popularity
      Home Photo
      20 Photos

      6 br 5 ba Single Family 4,200 sq ft $232/sq ft 2.0 acre lot Built: 2000 On ZipRealty 14 days Map

      This Beautifully Designed 6Br 4.5Ba Victorian Sits On Top Of A Hill In A Cul De Sac With Wrap... more
      Save Ask Visit Share
      Listing Provided Courtesy of Prudential Douglas Elliman Re Popularity
      Home Photo
      20 Photos

      0 br 0 ba Multi-Family 4,960 sq ft $323/sq ft 7.7 acre lot Built: 2000 On ZipRealty 18 days Map

      Situated On Almost 8 Acres Lies This Beautifully Designed Home Built In 2000, Historic Cottage,... more
      Save Ask Visit Share
      Listing Provided Courtesy of Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty
      Home Photo
      20 Photos

      4 br 3 ba Single Family 1,775 sq ft $484/sq ft 31,074 sq. ft. lot Built: 1807 On ZipRealty 22 days Map

      Built in 1807, the 'magnolia cottage' has been lovingly restored and thoughtfully expanded. A... more
      Save Ask Visit Share
      Listing Provided Courtesy of Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty Popularity
      Home Photo
      7 Photos

      0 br 0 ba Land N/A sq ft N/A/sq ft 40,510 sq. ft. lot Built: N/A On ZipRealty 26 days Map

      This Buildable Lot Abutts And Has Views Over Gardiners Bay Country Club And Has Enough Room For A... more
      Save Ask Visit Share
      Listing Provided Courtesy of Brown Harris Stevens Whampton Popularity
      Home Photo
      16 Photos

      3 br 2 ba Single Family 1,500 sq ft $333/sq ft 43,560 sq. ft. lot Built: 1979 On ZipRealty 36 days Map

      Ranch Style Home On 1 Acre At The End Of A Culdesac. This Is A Nice Quiet Neighborhood. Roof-... more
      Save Ask Visit Share
      Listing Provided Courtesy of Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty
      Home Photo
      16 Photos

      6 br 4 ba Single Family 3,928 sq ft $662/sq ft 15,246 sq. ft. lot Built: 1883 On ZipRealty 40 days Map

      This Charming Waterfront Victorian Features 6 Bedrooms, 3.5 Bathrooms, Living Room With... more
      Save Ask Visit Share
      Listing Provided Courtesy of Brown Harris Stevens Whampton
      Home Photo
      19 Photos

      4 br 2 ba Single Family 2,929 sq ft $184/sq ft 43,560 sq. ft. lot Built: 1999 On ZipRealty 52 days Map

      Move In Ready With Upgrades. Bathroom Has Newly Installed Suntube And Hardwood Floors. Jacuzzi... more
      Save Ask Visit Share
      Listing Provided Courtesy of Rosehip Partners Llc
      Home Photo
      12 Photos

      3 br 2 ba Single Family 1,576 sq ft $378/sq ft 27,007 sq. ft. lot Built: 1970 On ZipRealty 55 days Map

      Welcome Home To This Well Maintained Shelter Island 3 Bedroom,2 Bath Expanded Ranch On .62 Lot... more
      Save Ask Visit Share
      Listing Provided Courtesy of Prudential Douglas Elliman Re Popularity
      Home Photo
      12 Photos

      0 br 0 ba Land N/A sq ft N/A/sq ft 26,571 sq. ft. lot Built: N/A On ZipRealty 56 days Map

      Absolutely Beautiful Lot Overlooking Shelter Island Golf Course. Walk 650 Feet To Crescent Beach... more
      Save Ask Visit Share
      Listing Provided Courtesy of Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty
      Home Photo
      18 Photos

      4 br 3 ba Single Family N/A sq ft N/A/sq ft 1.3 acre lot Built: 1954 On ZipRealty 63 days Map

      Nature Lovers Retreat! 4 Bedroom,3 Bath Contemporary Sited On 1.2 Acres With Approximately 170 Ft... more
      Save Ask Visit Share
      Listing Provided Courtesy of Prudential Douglas Elliman Re
      Home Photo
      6 Photos

      0 br 0 ba Land N/A sq ft N/A/sq ft 9.7 acre lot Built: N/A On ZipRealty 75 days Map

      This Irreplaceable Estate On The Historic Isle Of Shelter Island Asserts A Total Of 9.74 Acres... more
      Save Ask Visit Share
      Listing Provided Courtesy of Coldwell Banker Showplace Rlty
      Home Photo
      20 Photos

      4 br 4 ba Single Family 2,854 sq ft $1,174/sq ft 1.4 acre lot Built: 1987 On ZipRealty 80 days Map

      Secluded Wf Beach House, Dock, Ws Pool; Outdoor Kitchen, Patio, Decks + Gazebo On 1.4 Acre Lot... more
      Save Ask Visit Share
      Listing Provided Courtesy of Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty
      Home Photo
      20 Photos

      4 br 2 ba Single Family 1,470 sq ft $418/sq ft 20,908 sq. ft. lot Built: 1970 On ZipRealty 86 days Map

      Very Close To Lake And Sandy, Sunset, Public Beach On Quiet Lane. Something Is Always Blooming On... more
      Save Ask Visit Share
      Listing Provided Courtesy of Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty Popularity
      Home Photo
      20 Photos

      5 br 2 ba Single Family 1,296 sq ft $1,002/sq ft 42,253 sq. ft. lot Built: 1964 On ZipRealty 88 days Map

      Newly Reduced, This Property Is Currently The Best Waterfront Value On Shelter Island. Call To... more
      Save Ask Visit Share
      Listing Provided Courtesy of Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty

      1 2 | Last
      Local real estate services provided by:
      Please contact us with any technical
      issues or questions about our services.
      1.800.225.5947
      House Photo
       
      1 of 1
      Loading....
      Loading
      The information being provided by LONGISLAND is for the consumer's personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumer may be interested in purchasing. Any information relating to real estate for sale referenced on this web site comes from the Internet Data Exchange (IDX) program of the LONGISLAND. ZipRealty, Inc. is not a Multiple Listing Service (MLS), nor does it offer MLS access. This website is a service of ZipRealty, Inc., a broker participant of LONGISLAND. This web site may reference real estate listing(s) held by a brokerage firm other than the broker and/or agent who owns this web site. Real estate listings held by brokerage firms other than this site owner are marked with the IDX/MLS logo.

      The accuracy of all information, regardless of source, including but not limited to open house information, square footages and lot sizes, is deemed reliable but not guaranteed and should be personally verified through personal inspection by and/or with the appropriate professionals. The data contained herein is copyrighted by LONGISLAND and is protected by all applicable copyright laws. Any unauthorized dissemination of this information is in violation of copyright laws and is strictly prohibited.

      Copyright 2012 LONGISLAND. All rights reserved.

      Data last updated: Monday, May 28, 2012 at 6:18 AM